About us
A small brokerage, on purpose
Arena Insurance Brokers is independent and locally owned. There is no call centre, no offshore service team and no account manager who changes every quarter. You deal with the person whose name is on the business.
Ashlee Stephens has been broking insurance in the Hunter for over a decade, and has run Arena as principal since 2019. The brokerage grew out of a simple observation: most people are not underinsured because they were careless. They are underinsured because nobody ever sat down and asked how the business actually works.
What we do differently
A broker's job has three parts, and the industry tends to do the first one well and the other two badly. The first is placing the cover. The second is reading the wording closely enough to know what it will do under pressure — the sub-limits, the excess structure, the exclusions that matter for your trade. The third is claims: being the person who lodges it, chases it and argues it when the insurer gets it wrong.
We are deliberately generalist. Across the 15 cover types we place, the same client often needs business, liability, fleet, cyber, home and travel. One broker holding all of it will spot the gap where two policies meet. Six different providers will not.
Independent, with real market access
Arena is an Authorised Representative of Community Broker Network Pty Ltd(AFSL 233750), one of Australia's largest general insurance broker networks. That gives a brokerage of our size access to the same insurer panel, wholesale wordings and underwriting agencies as a national firm — while the advice and the relationship stay entirely local.
In practice that matters most on difficult risks: a period home in Hamilton that direct insurers will not quote, a trade needing a specific principal endorsement for a Hunter builder, or a business with a claims history that needs presenting properly rather than submitted through a portal.
Where we work
We are based at Warners Bay on Lake Macquarie. Most clients are within half an hour — Newcastle, the lake, Maitland, up the valley and out to Port Stephens. We also look after clients elsewhere in New South Wales and interstate, usually because they moved or were referred by someone we already act for.
How we work
Four things we hold to
We work for you
A broker is your agent, not the insurer's. Everything from how we present your risk to how we argue a claim follows from that. If an insurer and a client disagree, we are on the client's side of the table.
Plain language, in writing
You will get a recommendation you can actually read, with the limits, excesses and exclusions set out. If we cannot explain why a policy suits you, it probably does not.
We would rather be right than quick
Rushed placements are where gaps come from. We ask more questions than you expect up front, because that is cheaper than finding out at claim time.
Honest when the answer is no
Sometimes your existing cover is already good, or the risk is better placed with a specialist. We will say so. A client we keep for fifteen years is worth more than a policy we win this month.
Talk to a broker
Let us look at what you are paying for
Send through your current policy schedules and we will tell you plainly what is covered, what is not, and whether the price is fair. No charge, no obligation.
Monday – Friday, 8:30am – 5:00pm · We call back the same day